Skip to main content
  • Moonlight Tavern & Supper Club logo top - Homepage
    Moonlight Tavern & Supper Club logo scroll - Homepage
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Parties
  • Jobs
  • Facebook page
  • Google page
Moonlight Tavern & Supper Club logo top - HomepageMoonlight Tavern & Supper Club logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Parties
  • Jobs

Our Menu

  • Menu
  • Friday Fish Fry
  • Prime Rib
  • Happy Hour

Small Plates

Lobster Claws (GF)
$30.00

1lb steamed lobster claws served with clarified butter & lemon

Seasonal Oysters* (GF)
MP

Served raw with cocktail sauce, lemon & mignonette | Rockefeller Style +$2.00

Italian Flatbread
$16.00

Mozzarella, romano, parmesan, provolone, house made marinara | Substitute GF crust +$4.00

Brie & Mushroom Flatbread
$16.00

Brie cheese, sliced house marinated mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, topped with balsamic & spinach | Substitute GF Crust +$4.00

Spinach Artichoke Dip
$14.00

Creamy warm spinach & artichoke dip served with an assortment of crackers can be served with GF rice crackers

Fried Balsamic Brussels
$13.00

Brussels sprouts fried to perfection, glazed with balsamic vinegar

Ashley's Deviled Eggs
$6.00

Four deviled eggs per order. Ask your server for current options

Wisconsin Cheese Curds
$13.00

Beer battered & fried white cheddar cheese curd with a side of ranch or marinara

Shrimp Cocktail
$18.00

Half pound of shrimp with cocktail sauce & lemon

Relish Tray
$9.00

A supper club classic!

Side of House Fries or Tater Tots
$5.00

Cajun Seasoning +$0.50 | Parmesan Black Truffle Garlic Seasoning +$0.50 | Upgrade to Loaded +$5.00 | Add Pulled Pork +$5.00

Salads

Add Protein: Chicken +$5.00 | Shrimp (4) +$8.00 | *Tenderloin +$12.00 •
Dressing Options: Peppercorn Parmesan, Ranch, Maple Balsamic, Italian, French, Caesar (contains anchovies and gluten), Honey Dijon, Blue Cheese, Thousand Island, Sunflower Seed, Oil & Vinegar, Pumpkin Vinaigrette

House Wedge (GF)
$16.00

Crisp iceberg lettuce, bacon crumbles, & tomato, with a creamy Gorgonzola dressing

Classic Caesar
$15.00

Romaine, croutons, Parmesan, & creamy Caesar dressing

Harvest Salad (GF)
$16.00

Mixed greens, roasted butternut squash, beets, pumpkin seed, goat cheese & sunflower seed Dressing or pumpkin vinaigrette

Handhelds

Choice of Fries or Tots

*Tenderloin Steak
$20.00

Hand-cut tenderloin sandwich, cooked to your desired temperature, served with Jameson Irish Whiskey sweet onions, & Swiss cheese on a Brioche bun

Twisted French Dip
$22.00

Shredded ribeye & provolone, on a sourdough baguette, with a side of Au Jus

Whiskey BBQ Pork
$18.00

Shredded pork, house made whiskey BBQ, & coleslaw, on Brioche bun

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$13.00

Marinated grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, & onion, on a Brioche bun | Add Cheese +$2.00

Classic Burger
$14.00

Broiled 1/3lb burger, lettuce, tomato, & onion on a Brioche bun | Add cheese +$2.00

Cuban Wrap
$16.00

Shredded pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickle, mustard mayo

Mains

Comes with choice of soup or salad. | Baked French Onion +$1.50

Chef Mate's Blackened Ahi Tuna
$30.00

Blackened Ahi Tuna served rare with seasoned jasmine rice & seasonal vegetables

New York Strip (GF)
$45.00

12 oz-14 oz | Bernie's Hand-cut Certified Choice Black Angus cooked to your liking, served alongside house marinated mushrooms, choice of potato & Au Jus

"Filet Mignon (GF)
$40.00

6 oz Bernie's Hand-cut filet cooked to your liking, served alongside house marinated mushrooms, choice of potato & Au Jus

Chicken Cordon Bleu
$30.00

House made chicken Cordon Bleu with a bechamel sauce over a bed of cauliflower mash & a side of seasonal vegetables

Mac N' Beer Cheese
$23.00

Cavatappi noodles with a house made beer cheese sauce

Parmesan Crusted Salmon
$30.00

Parmesan crust over a bed of seasoned jasmine rice with a side of seasonal vegetables

Autumn Linguine
$25.00

Roasted Butternut squash, mushrooms, spinach, garlic, sage red wine cream sauce, & linguine

Shrimp Piccatta
$28.00

Pan fried shrimp, on a bed of linguine, sauteed in a lemon caper sauce, with grated Parmesan cheese

Chef Paul's Tenderloin Strogonoff
$28.00

Tenderloin tips, mushrooms, garlic, & onions in a cream sauce on a bed of egg noodles

Pork Schnitzel
$28.00

Hand breaded fried pork & house made spaetzle topped with a mushroom gravy

Friday's only

Entrees

Served with soup or salad, choice of potato, coleslaw & tartar sauce.

Fried Shrimp
$18.00

(5) Shrimp battered & fried

Great Lake Perch
$22.00

Pan-fried or battered & fried

Haddock
$21.00

Pan-fried, broiled, or battered & fried

Saturday's only

Prime Rib Cuts

Bernie's Certified Black Angus served with Au Jus, house marinated mushrooms, your choice of potato & the option of soup or salad.

Duchess Cut
$35.00/8-10oz
Queen Cut
$45.00/12-14oz
King Cut
$55.00/18-20oz

Tuesday - Friday 2PM to 6 PM

Drinks

All Tap Beer
$5.00
Whiskey 2 Oz
$5.00

Jack Daniels, Jim Beam, Jameson Irish, Old Forester 86, or Basil Hayden

Vodka/ Gin 2 Oz
$5.00

Tito's Vodka, Wheatley Vodka, or Ford's Gin

House Wines
$5.00

Cabernet, Pinot Noir, Chardonnay, or Pinot Grigio

Food

WI Cheese Curds
$8.00
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$8.00
Brie & Mushroom Flatbread
$8.00
Italian Flatbread
$8.00
Relish Tray
$8.00
Fried Balsamic Brussels
$8.00
Loaded Fries or Tots
$8.00
Raw Oysters
$1.00
  • Parties
  • Jobs